Property & Casualty Insurance industry stocks
45 companies in the Property & Casualty Insurance industry. 43 have a published intrinsic value and 23 trade at least 20% below it.
The median company in Property & Casualty Insurance with a published value trades 22% below our estimate of intrinsic value.
Values as of the 22 Sept 2026 close.
Most undervalued stocks in Property & Casualty Insurance
- White Mountains Insurance Group Ltd (WTM): undervalued, +65% margin of safety
- American Coastal Insurance Corp (ACIC): undervalued, +60% margin of safety
- Allstate Corp (ALL): undervalued, +55% margin of safety
- Heritage Insurance Holdings Inc (HRTG): undervalued, +54% margin of safety
- American Integrity Insurance Group Inc (AII): undervalued, +53% margin of safety
- Universal Insurance Holdings Inc (UVE): undervalued, +47% margin of safety
- Mercury General Corp (MCY): undervalued, +46% margin of safety
- Slide Insurance Holdings Inc (SLDE): undervalued, +43% margin of safety
- Hippo Holdings Inc (HIPO): undervalued, +43% margin of safety
- Cincinnati Financial Corp (CINF): undervalued, +42% margin of safety
Liquid names only: at least $1M traded a day and $50M of market value.
Largest companies in Property & Casualty Insurance
- Chubb Limited (CB): undervalued, +24% margin of safety
- Progressive Corp (PGR): fairly valued, +3% margin of safety
- Travelers Companies Inc (TRV): undervalued, +21% margin of safety
- Allstate Corp (ALL): undervalued, +55% margin of safety
- Cincinnati Financial Corp (CINF): undervalued, +42% margin of safety
- W.R. Berkley Corp (WRB): fairly valued, -2% margin of safety
- Markel Group Inc (MKL): undervalued, +31% margin of safety
- Loews Corp (L): slightly undervalued, +6% margin of safety
- Assurant Inc (AIZ): slightly undervalued, +10% margin of safety
- CNA Financial Corp (CNA): undervalued, +34% margin of safety
- American Financial Group Inc (AFG): slightly undervalued, +8% margin of safety
- Old Republic International Corp (ORI): undervalued, +39% margin of safety
- Kinsale Capital Group Inc (KNSL): overvalued, -24% margin of safety
- Hanover Insurance Group Inc (THG): undervalued, +22% margin of safety
- Mercury General Corp (MCY): undervalued, +46% margin of safety
- RLI Corp (RLI): fairly valued, -2% margin of safety
- Selective Insurance Group Inc (SIGI): undervalued, +32% margin of safety
- White Mountains Insurance Group Ltd (WTM): undervalued, +65% margin of safety
- Hagerty Inc (HGTY): overvalued, -687% margin of safety
- Lemonade Inc (LMND): overvalued, -638% margin of safety
- Palomar Holdings Inc (PLMR): overvalued, -33% margin of safety
- Slide Insurance Holdings Inc (SLDE): undervalued, +43% margin of safety
- Skyward Specialty Insurance Group Inc (SKWD): slightly undervalued, +15% margin of safety
- HCI Group Inc (HCI): undervalued, +33% margin of safety
- Porch Group Inc (PRCH): not valued
- Stewart Information Services Corp (STC): slightly overvalued, -17% margin of safety
- Horace Mann Educators Corp (HMN): undervalued, +22% margin of safety
- Kemper Corp (KMPR): undervalued, +30% margin of safety
- Safety Insurance Group Inc (SAFT): overvalued, -72% margin of safety
- United Fire Group Inc (UFCS): undervalued, +36% margin of safety
- Ategrity Specialty Insurance Company Holdings (ASIC): slightly undervalued, +16% margin of safety
- Universal Insurance Holdings Inc (UVE): undervalued, +47% margin of safety
- Bowhead Specialty Holdings Inc (BOW): overvalued, -26% margin of safety
- Orion180 Insurance Group Inc (OIG): not valued
- Trupanion Inc (TRUP): overvalued, -291% margin of safety
- Heritage Insurance Holdings Inc (HRTG): undervalued, +54% margin of safety
- Hippo Holdings Inc (HIPO): undervalued, +43% margin of safety
- Root Inc (ROOT): overvalued, -47% margin of safety
- Donegal Group Inc (DGICA): undervalued, +33% margin of safety
- American Integrity Insurance Group Inc (AII): undervalued, +53% margin of safety
- American Coastal Insurance Corp (ACIC): undervalued, +60% margin of safety
- Global Indemnity Group LLC (GBLI): slightly undervalued, +10% margin of safety
- NI Holdings Inc (NODK): overvalued, -165% margin of safety
- Kingstone Cos. Inc (KINS): undervalued, +32% margin of safety
- Presurance Holdings Inc (PRHI): fairly valued, -3% margin of safety
Other Financial industries
All industries